Adam Savage's Issue With A.I.-Generated Art
TLDRThe transcript discusses the complex feelings towards AI in filmmaking, with a focus on its impact on the creative process and employment. The speaker acknowledges AI's potential to refine creativity but expresses concern over the loss of human perspective in art. They also highlight the importance of a champion in the success of a film and share insights on the portrayal of emotions through various film elements.
Takeaways
- 🤖 AI's role in filmmaking is seen as both promising and complex by J Delarosa, who acknowledges its potential to refine the creative process.
- 🎨 The impact of AI on the art and film industry is a topic of fascination for Delarosa, with a particular interest in how AI generates talking and visual content from text.
- 🚀 AI's capability to produce a high volume of content, such as illustrations, is noted as a significant advancement in the creative process.
- 📈 Delarosa expresses concern about the commercial implications of AI, especially its potential to replace human jobs in various industries.
- 💡 The lack of a distinct point of view in AI-generated art is identified as a drawback by Delarosa, who values the human element behind any creation.
- 🧠 Marvin Minsky's quote about the danger of AI that hides its intelligence is referenced, highlighting the need for caution with AI advancements.
- 🎥 The early days of AI in visual content creation are discussed, with the credits of 'Secret Invasion' being a notable example.
- 🧹 Delarosa shares insights on the process of creating and weathering film props, emphasizing the importance of detail and realism.
- 📚 The lightweight nature of the original Indiana Jones coat is highlighted, showing that replicas often fail to capture the exact characteristics of the original.
- 🌟 The portrayal of emotion in a film is a complex interplay of various elements such as the actors' abilities, the script, score, and lighting.
- 🎬 The importance of having a champion for a film is stressed, as it is believed to be a common factor in the success of great films.
Q & A
What is J Delarosa's perspective on the use of AI in filmmaking?
-J Delarosa finds the prospect of AI in filmmaking complicated. While acknowledging the benefits of AI in streamlining the creative process, such as generating numerous visual concepts quickly, Delarosa expresses concern about the lack of a unique point of view in AI-generated art, which is essential for him to appreciate any creation.
How does an AI illustrator compare to a traditional illustrator according to the director J Delarosa had dinner with?
-The director mentioned that an AI illustrator can produce hundreds of pictures a day, compared to a traditional illustrator who might only create a drawing or a painting per day. This indicates that AI can significantly speed up the generation process, but may lack the personalized touch of a human artist.
What issue does J Delarosa have with AI-generated art?
-J Delarosa's main issue with AI-generated art is the perceived lack of a distinct point of view. Delarosa values the mind and heart behind a creation, and has yet to see an AI exhibit a point of view that resonates with him on a personal level.
How does J Delarosa feel about the commercial aspect of AI replacing human jobs?
-Delarosa is deeply concerned and frustrated about the commercial aspect of AI, particularly when it comes to replacing human jobs. He views this as a symptom of late-stage capitalism and finds the idea of using AI to cut costs and let go of employees to be lazy and problematic.
What does J Delarosa think about the use of AI in radio DJ hosting?
-Delarosa is critical of the use of AI in radio DJ hosting. He mentions an instance where a radio station used an AI host for late-night programming and expresses his disapproval, suggesting that it could lead to potential issues and that such a use of AI is something that genuinely bothers him.
What is J Delarosa's approach to weathering film props?
-Delarosa weathers film props by making the details more obvious than they might appear to the naked eye, as cameras often do not capture the same level of detail as the human eye. He uses a camera to assess the paint jobs and weathering, comparing it to how his father, a painter, would assess his work from a distance to find high spots or areas needing more attention.
What surprised J Delarosa about the props used in films?
-Delarosa was surprised by the dirtiness and the lightweight nature of many film props. He specifically mentions Indiana Jones' coat from 'Raiders of the Lost Ark', which is much lighter than most replicas, and how the camera can minimize the appearance of weathering and detail on props.
What does J Delarosa believe is the biggest impact in portraying emotion in a film?
-Delarosa believes that the biggest impact in portraying emotion in a film comes from a confluence of factors including the actor's ability, the script, the score, and the lighting. He also emphasizes the importance of having at least one person championing the film and bringing it into being.
How does J Delarosa view the role of AI in the future of filmmaking?
-While Delarosa is still somewhat concerned about the aesthetic implications of AI in filmmaking, he feels that it will be extremely difficult for AI to exhibit a truly distinct and personal point of view that can resonate with him. He is more worried about the employment impact of AI, rather than its aesthetic potential in the film industry.
What did J Delarosa learn from Guillermo del Toro about the making of a great film?
-Guillermo del Toro shared with Delarosa that there is no way to predict if a film will be great during its making. However, a common factor in every great film is the presence of at least one person who champions the film, ensuring its creation and success.
How does J Delarosa describe the filmmaking process?
-Delarosa describes the filmmaking process as an alchemy, a magical confluence of factors that cannot be formulaically replicated. He believes that for any piece of art to be truly great, it requires this alchemical process, which is unique and cannot be reduced to a simple formula.
Outlines
🤖 AI in Filmmaking
In this paragraph, J Delarosa discusses the complex feelings towards the increasing use of AI in filmmaking. They mention a conversation with a list director who appreciates how AI makes his creative process more iterative, allowing for the generation of numerous visual concepts. J Delarosa acknowledges the potential benefits of AI in refining the creative process but expresses concern about the lack of a personal point of view in AI-generated art. They also touch on the issue of AI replacing human jobs and the potential negative impacts of late-stage capitalism on the film industry.
🎨 Film Props and Realism
This paragraph focuses on the surprises of film props when viewed in person, particularly their dirtiness and the level of detail required to create a realistic appearance. The speaker shares personal experiences with replicating K's coat and boots, emphasizing the importance of assessing weathering through a camera lens. They also discuss the lightweight nature of Indiana Jones' coat from 'Raiders' compared to the heavier replicas available, highlighting the challenge of capturing the essence of original props.
🎥 The Art of Filmmaking
The speaker delves into the art of filmmaking, discussing the various elements that contribute to portraying emotions in a film, such as the actor's abilities, the script, the score, and the lighting. They share a conversation with Guillermo del Toro about the unpredictability of a film's success and the necessity of a champion for every great film. The paragraph also addresses the alchemy of art, the lack of a formula for creating truly impactful art, and the speaker's concerns about AI's potential lack of a distinct, personal point of view in art and its implications for employment in various industries.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡AI in filmmaking
💡Emerging technologies
💡Creative process
💡Point of view
💡Late-stage capitalism
💡Union negotiations
💡Artificial intelligence
💡迭代
💡视觉特效
💡就业
💡情感表达
Highlights
J Delarosa's perspective on AI in filmmaking as both a community member and technology enthusiast.
The impact of AI on the creative process, making it more iterative and cost-effective for filmmakers.
The fascination with AI and its current state in the industry, particularly in text-to-video applications.
The concern over AI-generated art lacking a personal point of view, which is essential for Delarosa's interest in any creation.
Marvin Minsky's quote on the potential dangers of AI that hides its intelligence, resonating with Delarosa's views.
The commercial implications of AI in industries, with the potential to replace human jobs, which Delarosa finds concerning.
The early days of AI visuals and their integration into film credits, such as in 'Secret Invasion'.
The importance of a personal point of view in art and creation, which Delarosa has yet to see in AI.
The potential for AI to be used innovatively in student films, before being overused by mainstream Hollywood.
ADHD Media's question on film props and Delarosa's experience with props in person.
The surprising nature of film props when seen in reality, particularly their condition and level of detail.
The technique of using a camera to assess the weathering on props, inspired by Delarosa's father's painting approach.
The lightweight nature of Indiana Jones' coat from 'Raiders' compared to replicas, which was a surprising discovery for Delarosa.
The biggest impact on portraying emotion in a film, with various factors like actors, script, score, and lighting.
Guillermo del Toro's insight on the unpredictability of a film's success and the importance of a film's champion.
The alchemy of filmmaking and art, with no formula for success, which Delarosa finds reassuring regarding AI's potential impact.
Delarosa's philosophical take on AI, focusing on employment concerns and the irreplaceable human element in art.