The Ultimate AI Photo Culling Face Off | Aftershoot vs. FilterPixel vs. Narrative Select
TLDRBritney, a former photographer and current user experience practitioner, reviews three AI photo culling software options: Aftershoot, FilterPixel, and Narrative Select. She evaluates them based on pricing, speed of culling, user interface, and call quality. Aftershoot and Narrative Select are the winners, with Aftershoot being the cheapest option and Narrative Select offering a flexible project-based free trial. Britney finds that all systems picked similar images, but the right balance between AI and human oversight is crucial. She concludes that while AI can speed up the workflow, it requires careful review to ensure quality, and she encourages others to test these systems for their own creative processes.
Takeaways
- π· Britney, a former photographer, explores AI photo culling software to streamline her workflow.
- π Three main AI photo culling systems are discussed: Aftershoot, FilterPixel, and Narrative Select.
- π° Pricing is a significant factor, with Aftershoot offering a $10/month plan, FilterPixel at $12/month, and Narrative Select at $15/month.
- β±οΈ Narrative Select outperforms the others in speed, culling images incredibly fast.
- π¨ Aftershoot's interface is well-organized, making it user-friendly, while FilterPixel's interface is compact and straightforward.
- π Narrative Select provides detailed image assessments, which Britney finds useful and cool.
- π οΈ Aftershoot offers a 'spray can' tool for bulk decisions and keyboard shortcuts for efficient navigation.
- π All systems allow drag-and-drop exporting, but FilterPixel provides a more straightforward export process.
- π€ AI technology in all three systems is similar, leading to nearly identical image selections.
- π€ Britney questions the true time savings of AI culling, as she still needs to review AI selections carefully.
- π Britney concludes that finding the right balance between AI and human effort is crucial for maximizing workflow efficiency.
- π She encourages others to try these systems and form their own opinions, acknowledging the continuous improvement in AI technology.
Q & A
What is the main topic of discussion in the video?
-The main topic of the video is a comparison of three AI photo culling software: Aftershoot, FilterPixel, and Narrative Select. The comparison is based on factors such as pricing, speed, user interface, and the quality of the culling process.
What is Britney's background according to the video?
-Britney is a former photographer who has transitioned into a user experience practitioner. She continues to have a strong interest in photography and discusses topics related to the field from a different perspective.
What is the significance of the 30-day free trial offered by Aftershoot?
-The 30-day free trial is significant because it provides users with an extended period to test the software during busy seasons, offering a full month of access to evaluate its effectiveness in their workflow.
Which software won the speed test in the video?
-Narrative Select won the speed test, with an incredibly fast processing time of approximately 3 seconds for 399 images.
What is the primary concern when using AI culling systems according to Britney?
-The primary concern is finding the right balance between relying on the AI for culling and providing human oversight to ensure quality, as blind trust in AI could lead to poor selections and wasted resources.
How does the user interface of Aftershoot contribute to its effectiveness?
-Aftershoot's user interface is well-organized with clear sectioning, offering tools like quick filters, advanced filters, and sorting options. It also provides tooltips and in-app video tutorials for assistance, making it user-friendly and efficient.
What does Britney find particularly useful in Narrative Select's interface?
-Britney finds the on-image eye and focus assessment shapes and colors particularly useful in Narrative Select, as they correspond to the same colors in the face mode side panel, providing clear information about the AI selections.
What is the most expensive system among the three that Britney reviewed?
-Narrative Select is the most expensive system, with its Select Pro tier costing $15 per month when billed annually.
What is the unique feature of Filter Pixel's free tier?
-Filter Pixel's free tier offers manual culling with no auto features, which is different from the other systems that focus on AI-assisted culling.
How does Britney feel about the AI technology used in the reviewed systems?
-Britney finds it interesting that despite being different brands with different interfaces, the core AI technology used for culling seems to be similarly tuned across the systems, as they often selected the same images.
What is Britney's conclusion about the effectiveness of AI culling systems in speeding up her workflow?
-Britney concludes that the effectiveness of AI culling systems in speeding up her workflow depends on finding the right balance between AI automation and human oversight. She plans to continue testing different oversight strategies to determine what works best for her.
Outlines
π Introduction to AI in Photography
Britney, a former photographer and current user experience practitioner, introduces the topic of artificial intelligence in the photography industry. She discusses her intention to explore different AI photo editing software options, such as Aftershoot, Filter Pixel, and Narrative, to determine which can streamline a photographer's workflow most effectively. Britney discloses her prior use of Aftershoot and her criteria for evaluation, which include pricing, speed, user interface, and call quality.
π° Pricing Comparison of AI Photo Software
The video delves into the pricing structures of the three AI photo software options. Aftershoot offers a 30-day free trial and a Select tier at $10 per month when billed annually. Filter Pixel provides a basic free tier and a Pro tier at $12 per month, also billed annually, with a 30-day free trial. Narrative Select stands out with a free option that includes six project trials and a Pro tier at $15 per month, billed annually. Britney appreciates the flexibility of Narrative Select's project-based trial and considers pricing a key factor in her evaluation.
β±οΈ Speed Test of AI Photo Software
Britney conducts a speed test using images from a wedding photographed in October 2023 to compare how quickly each system can process and select images. Aftershoot takes 4 minutes and 48 seconds, her manual selection takes 4 minutes and 26 seconds, Filter Pixel takes 4 minutes and 4 seconds, and Narrative Select astonishingly completes the task in about 3 seconds. The results highlight Narrative Select's superior speed in image selection.
π₯οΈ User Interface and Experience
The video examines the user interfaces of the three systems. Aftershoot is praised for its organized layout and helpful tooltips. Filter Pixel's interface is more compact, with a straightforward design and a helpful tutorial video. Narrative Select offers a feature-rich sidebar and detailed information on image assessments. Britney finds Aftershoot's interface most appealing due to its structured layout and quick tutorial.
π’ System Communication and Feedback
Britney evaluates how each system communicates with users about image selections. Aftershoot provides email alerts, tooltips, and hover text for clarity. Filter Pixel uses tooltips and hover information efficiently, with a focus on simplicity. Narrative Select offers extensive communication, including on-image assessments and informative tooltips. Britney finds Narrative Select's detailed communication particularly useful.
π Correcting AI Selections
The video discusses the ease of correcting AI mistakes within each system. Aftershoot offers a spray can tool and smooth navigation in Loop mode for efficient corrections. Filter Pixel allows for right-click options and keyboard shortcuts for changes but requires more keyboard stretching. Narrative Select's duplicate viewing is less efficient, but it provides clear assessments on image quality. Britney finds Aftershoot's interface most user-friendly for corrections.
π€ Exporting Images from AI Software
Britney assesses the exporting process for each system. All three allow drag-and-drop functionality, but Aftershoot's export menu is deemed too complex. Filter Pixel's export process is straightforward, making it the most convenient for those looking to export to a folder or application. Narrative Select's export, labeled 'ship,' is simple but has undergone recent updates to improve functionality.
π Final Judgment on AI Photo Software
In the final analysis, Britney finds that Aftershoot and Narrative Select are the winners, each scoring two points. She notes that all systems selected similar images, suggesting they use similarly tuned AI technology. However, she expresses difficulty in determining the exact time savings and productivity gains from using AI, as manual oversight is still required. Britney concludes that finding a balance between AI and human effort is crucial and encourages viewers to test these systems for themselves.
π’ Closing Remarks and Invitation for Feedback
Britney thanks viewers for watching and invites them to share their thoughts on AI photo editing software in the comments section. She expresses her eagerness to discuss AI's role in photography further and encourages viewers to like, subscribe, and comment on what they'd like her to explore next.
Mindmap
Keywords
π‘AI Photo Culling
π‘Aftershoot
π‘Filter Pixel
π‘Narrative Select
π‘User Experience
π‘Pricing
π‘Smart Tech
π‘Workflow
π‘Interface Design
π‘Exporting
π‘AI Selection Quality
Highlights
Britney, a former photographer turned user experience practitioner, discusses the role of artificial intelligence in photo culling.
Three major AI photo culling systems are reviewed: Aftershoot, FilterPixel, and Narrative Select.
Aftershoot is noted for its prominent free trial offer andζη» (bundling) AI with editing in higher tiers.
FilterPixel offers a basic free tier and a Pro tier with a 30-day free trial, recently extended from 14 days.
Narrative Select provides a unique project-based free trial, alleviating time pressure for users.
Pricing is a key consideration, with Aftershoot being the cheapest option, but Narrative Select's flexible trial is highly valued.
A speed test is conducted on 399 images, with Narrative Select completing the task in just 3 seconds.
The user interface of each system is evaluated, with Aftershoot praised for its organized elements and clear sectioning.
FilterPixel's interface is compact, with a focus on simplicity and ease of use.
Narrative Select's interface is feature-rich with a lighter theme and detailed subject views.
Aftershoot's communication with users is highly prioritized, offering tooltips, email alerts, and a feedback tool.
FilterPixel uses tooltips and hover information for effective communication within its streamlined design.
Narrative Select provides extensive information and assessments on images, enhancing user understanding of AI selections.
The ease of correcting AI mistakes is explored, with Aftershoot offering a more efficient navigation and customization options.
Exporting capabilities are compared, with FilterPixel providing a straightforward process for exporting images.
The overall quality of the call is challenging to judge, as all three systems selected similar images, including some errors.
Britney concludes that finding the right balance between AI and human oversight is crucial for maximizing workflow efficiency.
She encourages viewers to test different AI culling systems to determine what works best for their individual needs.