『専門学校生』対『ＡＩ』でイラスト対決...教える講師は「負けちゃうのは仕方ないのでほかにどういう道が残っているか探さないと」【ＡＩは仕事を奪う？】（2022年12月7日）
TLDRThe video script discusses the impact of AI on the field of illustration, particularly among students at a specialized school aiming to become illustrators. It highlights the rapid advancement of AI in creating digital art, causing concern among students that their skills may become obsolete. The script features an experiment comparing the speed and quality of human and AI-generated illustrations, showing that while AI is faster, human artists excel in quality. The introduction of a service called Mimic, which can replicate an illustrator's style, has stirred debate about the ethical use of AI in art. Despite these challenges, one student remains hopeful about pursuing a career in character design, considering the possibility of coexisting with AI in the creative field.
Takeaways
- 🎨 Digital illustration is increasingly integrated into art education, reflecting the growing importance of technology in the field.
- 🤖 AI technology has advanced to the point where it can create illustrations, raising concerns among art students about the future of their skills.
- 🚀 AI can produce illustrations quickly, potentially outpacing human artists in terms of speed, but may not match the quality and nuances of human-created art.
- 🌟 Despite the capabilities of AI, human artists' unique styles and personal touches remain valuable and irreplaceable.
- 🔍 AI's ability to mimic specific artists' styles has sparked debates about originality and the potential misuse of personal artistic styles.
- 🚦 Services like Mimic allow AI to learn from and replicate the styles of renowned artists, raising ethical questions about authorship and artistic integrity.
- 📝 The AI-generated art can be a tool for artists, but the concern is whether it will lead to a loss of unique human creativity.
- 🌐 The art industry is at a crossroads, questioning whether AI will replace human jobs or if a coexistence is possible.
- 🔄 The future of the creative industry will be shaped by how well humans and AI can collaborate and complement each other's strengths.
- 🌟 Aspiring illustrators, like the student in the script, continue to pursue their dreams despite the challenges posed by AI, considering the possibility of different roles in the industry.
Q & A
What is the main concern of art students regarding AI in illustration?
-Art students are concerned that AI might replace human illustrators, making their skills and the time they've spent honing their craft obsolete, especially with AI's ability to create illustrations quickly with just a click.
How does AI integrate into art education?
-AI is increasingly being integrated into art education, with digital illustration tools being incorporated into the curriculum, allowing students to learn and adapt to new technologies in the field.
What is the impact of AI on the speed of illustration creation?
-AI significantly increases the speed of illustration creation, with the ability to generate an illustration in seconds compared to the traditional method which can take much longer.
What are the advantages of AI in illustration?
-AI offers efficiency and cost-effectiveness, the ability to quickly generate a large volume of illustrations, and the flexibility to mimic different artistic styles, making it an attractive option for various industries.
What are the potential drawbacks of AI-generated illustrations?
-AI-generated illustrations may lack the emotional depth and originality of human-created art, and their widespread use could lead to a homogenization of visual styles across platforms.
How can human illustrators adapt to the rise of AI in the industry?
-Illustrators can adapt by embracing AI as a complementary tool, using it to streamline certain tasks, and focusing on bringing unique perspectives and emotions to their work that AI cannot replicate.
What is the role of AI in mimicking specific art styles?
-AI can be trained to learn specific art styles and create new illustrations in the manner of renowned artists, making it possible to generate art that closely resembles the work of the original creator.
How do professionals in the art industry view the collaboration between AI and human illustrators?
-While some professionals express concern about job security and the potential loss of originality, others see the collaboration between AI and human illustrators as a way to enhance productivity and explore new creative avenues.
What is the current state of AI's ability to replace human illustrators?
-Although AI has made significant strides, it is not yet able to fully replace human illustrators, as it lacks the emotional depth and nuanced storytelling that human artists bring to their work.
What is the future outlook for the illustration industry with the integration of AI?
-The future of illustration is expected to involve a symbiotic relationship between human creativity and AI assistance, with illustrators leveraging AI to increase efficiency and expand their skillset while maintaining their unique creative vision.
Outlines
🎨 The Emergence of AI in Illustration
This paragraph discusses the integration of AI in the field of illustration, particularly within specialized schools where students are being trained to become illustrators. It highlights the shift towards digital illustration and the students' concerns about AI potentially surpassing their skills. The narrative includes a scenario where students interact with an AI service that can create illustrations based on text descriptions, such as a bear eating spaghetti, and compares the speed and quality of human and AI-generated art. The segment also touches on the potential future where AI could impact the job market for illustrators and the need for artists to adapt to these technological advancements.
🤖 AI's Impact on Creativity and the Illustration Industry
The second paragraph delves into the impact of AI on the creative process and the illustration industry. It discusses the capabilities of AI to mimic specific illustrators' styles, as demonstrated by the Mimic service launched in August, which can generate new illustrations in the style of famous artists like Van Gogh and Hokusai. The segment also addresses the concerns of illustrators about AI potentially stealing their unique styles and the ethical implications of such technology. The narrative concludes with a look at the future, questioning whether AI will take over human jobs or if there can be a coexistence where both AI and human artists can thrive and complement each other's work.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Illustration
💡Digital Illustration
💡AI (Artificial Intelligence)
💡Vocational School
💡Insecurity
💡One-Click AI
💡Quality vs. Speed
💡Mimicry
💡Creative Field
💡Illustration Teacher
💡Coexistence
Highlights
Students at a specialized school are concerned about the impact of AI on their future careers in illustration.
Digital illustration has become mainstream and is now incorporated into the curriculum of art schools.
AI can create illustrations that surprise students with their quality, leading them to worry about the value of their own skills.
AI can create illustrations in a matter of seconds, which is faster than traditional methods.
The LINE account service allows users to send text descriptions and receive AI-generated illustrations.
AI can replicate the style of famous artists like Van Gogh and create illustrations in their unique styles.
AI-generated illustrations can mimic the styles of traditional Japanese artists like Katsushika Hokusai.
Students like Yuki Maehara, specializing in character illustration, worry about being replaced by AI in the future.
A comparison between human and AI illustration shows that while AI is faster, humans offer a unique quality.
The quality of AI-generated illustrations is expected to surpass human artists in the near future.
AI's ability to mimic specific illustrators' styles has sparked debates about the ethical use of such technology.
The Mimic service, which started in August, allows AI to learn from and replicate the styles of illustrators.
There were initial concerns about the misuse of AI to steal artists' styles, leading to the temporary suspension of the service.
The service now strictly checks that only the illustrators themselves can use their styles in AI-generated works.
Yuki Maehara considers the possibility of coexisting with AI, envisioning a future where both humans and AI create art.
The impact of AI on creative fields raises questions about whether it will take over human jobs or if a symbiotic relationship is possible.
The story highlights the innovative use of AI in the field of illustration and the potential for it to transform artistic creation.
The narrative explores the concerns and hopes of students and professionals in the face of AI's rapid advancement in art.