COMPARING EVERY UNIFI PROTECT CAMERA 2024
TLDRIn this comprehensive review, Clay Archer from DPC Technology evaluates a range of Ubiquiti cameras, comparing their performance in various conditions. The cameras are tested for image quality, feature set, and form factor, with a focus on both indoor and outdoor capabilities. Despite some issues with the API and Theta models, the G5 series, particularly the G5 Pro and G5 Dome, emerge as top performers, offering excellent image quality and reliable performance for commercial and home use. The review also highlights the importance of choosing the right camera for specific needs and budgets, with the AI Pro taking the top spot for its advanced features and versatility.
Takeaways
- ๐ The CEO of DPC Technology, Clay Archer, conducts a comprehensive review of Ubiquiti cameras, rating them from worst to first based on various factors.
- ๐ธ Each camera is tested for both day and night performance, with a focus on image quality, feature set, form factor, and sound.
- ๐ฐ The review highlights the price points of different camera models, noting the G4 PTZ's current sale price at $999, and the affordability of the G5 Pro at $379.
- ๐ The comparison includes a range of cameras from the high-end AI-enabled models to more budget-friendly options like the G3 Flex and G3 Instant.
- ๐ The G5 Dome and G5 Flex่ฑ้ข่ๅบ, receiving praise for their high-resolution sensors and excellent image quality.
- ๐ฅ The video emphasizes the importance of choosing the right camera for specific use cases, whether for home, office, or outdoor surveillance.
- ๐ The review points out the durability and reliability of certain models, with some Theta cameras experiencing issues during testing.
- ๐ The script mentions the availability of smart detections like license plate recognition, which is a significant feature for some users.
- ๐ Sound quality is briefly tested, with the G5 Bullet noted for its ability to handle background noise effectively.
- ๐ Nighttime tests reveal the strengths of certain cameras in low-light conditions, with the G5 Pro and Air Pro standing out for their infrared emitters and sensor sensitivity.
- ๐ The video concludes with a ranked list of the cameras, recommending the G5 Pro, G5 Flex, and G5 Dome for general use due to their balance of performance and value.
Q & A
What is the main purpose of the video?
-The main purpose of the video is to review and rate various Ubiquiti cameras, comparing their features, image quality, and performance in different scenarios.
Which Ubiquiti camera model is not included in the review?
-The AI DSLR camera is not included in the review.
What are some of the factors considered in rating the cameras?
-The factors considered in rating the cameras include image quality, feature set, form factor, and sound quality.
How many cameras did Clay Archer test and rate in the video?
-Clay Archer tested and rated 20 different Ubiquiti cameras in the video.
What is the G4 PTZ's current sale price?
-The G4 PTZ's current sale price is $800.
What is the main advantage of the G5 Pro camera mentioned in the video?
-The main advantage of the G5 Pro camera is its optical zoom and high-resolution sensor, which provides excellent image quality and the ability to perform license plate detection.
Which camera model had issues with setup during the API testing process?
-One of the Theta models had issues with setup during the API testing process, as it came DOA (Dead on Arrival) and took a couple of weeks to resolve through the warranty process.
What is the main difference between the G5 Dome and G4 Dome cameras?
-The main difference between the G5 Dome and G4 Dome cameras is the image quality and HDR capabilities. The G5 Dome has a five-megapixel HDR sensor, while the G4 Dome has a standard five-megapixel sensor. The G5 Dome also has better build quality and a wider field of view.
What is the most expensive camera reviewed in the video?
-The most expensive camera reviewed in the video is the G4 PTZ, which is currently on sale for $999, but originally retails for $1299.
What is the general conclusion about the evolution of Ubiquiti cameras?
-The general conclusion is that in the evolution of Ubiquiti cameras, there are no longer any 'dog' cameras in the lineup. All the cameras reviewed provide good performance and image quality, with some models standing out more based on specific features and use cases.
Outlines
๐ฅ Introduction and Overview of Camera Testing
The video begins with Clay Archer, CEO of DPC Technology, introducing the purpose of the video: to test and rate various Ubiquiti cameras from worst to first. The testing includes both indoor and outdoor cameras, with the exception of the AI DSLR due to its niche market and high cost. The focus is on evaluating the quality of image, feature set, form factor, and other relevant aspects. The video also mentions previous testing results and the evolution of camera quality over time. The setup for the test rig is described, along with the intention to test sound from each camera. The video promises a link to a detailed blog post for those interested in the nitty-gritty of each camera's features and ratings.
๐ Evolution and Performance of Ubiquiti Cameras
This paragraph discusses the evolution of Ubiquiti cameras, noting a significant improvement in performance with fewer underperformers in the current group. The categorization of the cameras into 'dome', 'flex', and 'instance' types is introduced, with a focus on their suitability for office settings. The G4 and G5 Dome cameras are highlighted for their five-megapixel sensor and HDR capabilities, respectively. The comparison extends to the G5 Flex, G3 Flex, and other models, emphasizing the image quality and sensor differences. The paragraph concludes with a brief mention of the smart detections available on the newer models and the lack thereof on the G3 line.
๐ Detailed Analysis of Bullet Cameras
The paragraph delves into the analysis of bullet cameras, emphasizing the importance of resolution and zoom capabilities. The G5 Pro and G4 Pro sensors are compared, noting the advancements in the newer G5 Pro. The discussion includes the dynamic range and color richness of the images produced by these cameras. The G4 Bolt and G4 Pro are pointed out for not having the dynamic range of other sensors, and the handling of light and dark elements in their images is discussed. The paragraph also touches on the different sensor sizes and their impact on image quality when zoomed in. The AI bullet is highlighted for its five-megapixel sensor, and the G5 bullet for its HDR capabilities and affordability over the G4 bullet. The paragraph concludes with a mention of the smart detections available on the G5 bullet, including license plate detection.
๐ Nighttime Testing and Infrared Emitters
The nighttime testing of the cameras is discussed, focusing on the infrared (IR) capabilities of most cameras, except for the Theta models which lack IR and license plate detection. The G5 Pro's IR emitter is noted for its strength, and the impact of the emitted light on the image quality of the cameras is analyzed. The paragraph also compares the images produced by the G4 Pro, G5 Pro, and G5 Bullet in low-light conditions, highlighting the contrast and visibility differences. The performance of the cameras in terms of their sensitivity to ambient light and the quality of the images produced in the dark is discussed, with the G5 Pro and G5 Bullet noted for their superior performance.
๐ข Office Setting Cameras and Their Performance
This paragraph focuses on the performance of cameras typically used in office settings, such as domes, flexes, and instances. The G5 Dome is declared the clear winner among them for its superior image quality and clarity. The G5 Flex and G4 Instant are also praised for their performance, with the G5 Flex noted for its powerful performance in a challenging environment. The paragraph also discusses the Wi-Fi-only G3 Instant camera, noting its decent performance despite streaming issues. The G5 Dome's IR emitter is highlighted as the strongest among the tested cameras, and the impact of the IR light on the image quality is discussed. The paragraph concludes with a comparison of the G5 Pro and G5 Dome in terms of their IR capabilities and overall performance.
๐ Low Light Performance of Theta Cameras
The performance of Theta cameras in low light conditions is the focus of this paragraph. The Theta cameras' sensitivity to light is praised, with the ability to recreate the actual darkness of the office environment noted. The Theta Pro models are highlighted for their superior performance in low light, with the Theta 360 Pro noted for its impressive detail in low light conditions. The paragraph also discusses the limitations of the Theta cameras when used outside, despite their good performance indoors. The Theta Pro's ability to detect license plates in low light is noted, and the color detail provided by the Theta cameras is highlighted. The paragraph concludes with a brief mention of the Theta cameras' performance in a normally lit environment.
๐ค๏ธ Challenging Daytime Conditions and Camera Performance
The paragraph discusses the testing of cameras under challenging daytime conditions, focusing on how well they handle harsh sunlight. The Theta cameras are noted for their struggle with direct sunlight, while the G5 Pro and G5 Flex models handle the conditions better. The paragraph also mentions a malfunction with one of the Theta cameras, raising questions about their durability. The G5 Dome's performance under an awning is praised, and the G5 Flex is noted as a potential outdoor option. The paragraph concludes with a general statement that all cameras performed adequately, but none were particularly amazing under these conditions.
๐ License Plate Detection and Sound Test
The paragraph focuses on the license plate detection capabilities of the cameras, a key feature for security purposes. The AI cameras are highlighted for their ability to detect license plates, and a demonstration of this feature is provided. The paragraph also includes a sound test of the cameras, with the G5 Bullet noted for its superior sound quality. The performance of the cameras in terms of sound is compared, with the G5 Pro and G4 Pro also performing well. The paragraph concludes with a discussion on the placement of cameras for optimal license plate detection and the importance of choosing the right camera for the specific use case.
๐ Nighttime Camera Performance and IR Emitters
The nighttime performance of the cameras is analyzed, with a focus on the IR emitters and their impact on image quality. The PTC camera is praised for its exceptional performance at night, particularly its ability to zoom and provide clear images. The IR emitters of the G5 Pro and G5 Bullet are tested and found to improve image quality. The paragraph also discusses the impact of IR light on license plate visibility and the overall effectiveness of the cameras in low-light conditions. The performance of the Theta cameras without IR emitters is noted, and the G5 Dome is highlighted for its good nighttime performance. The paragraph concludes with a discussion on the importance of choosing cameras with the right features for the specific environment.
๐ Ranking of Cameras from Worst to Best
The paragraph presents a ranking of the cameras from worst to best, based on their performance and value. The G4 Pro, G4 Bullet, and G4 Dome are ranked low due to their older technology and higher prices compared to newer models. The G3 models are also ranked low but are noted for their decent performance at a lower price point. The paragraph then discusses the Theta cameras, noting their potential but also their current limitations in terms of reliability and practicality in installation. The top ten cameras are introduced, with the G5 Pro, G5 Flex, and G5 Bullet highly ranked for their performance and features.
๐ Top-Rated Cameras and Final Thoughts
The paragraph concludes the video with the top five cameras as ranked by the reviewer. The G5 Pro is praised for its all-around performance and image quality, despite its additional cost. The G5 Flex is noted for its versatility and affordability, making it a top choice for various applications. The G5 Bullet is recognized for its solid performance and value. The G5 Dome is highlighted as a workhorse camera for offices, known for its reliability and image quality. The AI Pro is ranked first for its comprehensive features, including license plate detection, and its ability to serve as a deterrent. The paragraph ends with the reviewer's acknowledgment of the subjective nature of the rankings and an invitation for viewers to share their opinions.
Mindmap
Keywords
๐กUbiquiti cameras
๐กTest rig
๐กAI DSLR
๐กImage quality
๐กForm factor
๐กOptical zoom
๐กAI features
๐กLicense plate detection
๐กNight vision
๐กPTZ (Pan-Tilt-Zoom)
Highlights
Clay Archer, CEO of DPC Technology, introduces a comprehensive review of Ubiquiti cameras.
The review involves testing every Ubiquiti camera except for the AI DSLR due to its niche market and high price point.
The cameras are tested both indoors and outdoors in day and night conditions to evaluate their performance.
Sound quality from each camera is briefly tested, with the understanding that audio is not the primary focus of these security cameras.
The review criteria include image quality, feature set, form factor, and overall value.
Ubiquiti's camera lineup has evolved to the point where there are no clear 'dog' cameras, only differences in form factor and price.
The G4 PTZ is highlighted as a pan-tilt-zoom camera with excellent optics, currently on sale for $800.
The G5 Pro and G4 Pro cameras are noted for their 8-megapixel sensors and optical zoom capabilities.
The AI Bullet and AI 360 Pro cameras are recognized for their affordability and AI features, priced at $399 each.
Theta cameras are discussed for their unique form factor and the strange packaging and pricing strategy.
The G5 Bullet is recommended for its superior image quality and price point compared to the G4 Bullet.
The G5 Dome and G5 Flex cameras are praised for their high-resolution sensors and wide-angle capabilities.
The review emphasizes the importance of choosing the right camera based on specific use cases and environments.
Nighttime tests reveal the strengths and weaknesses of each camera's infrared and low-light performance.
The Air Pro's license plate detection feature is highlighted as a significant advancement in security camera technology.
The review concludes with a ranking of all tested cameras, with the G5 Pro, G5 Flex, and G5 Domeไฝๅๅ่ .