What worries me most about AI art | Art Talk

Joao Marcedo
31 Mar 202407:31

TLDRThe speaker reflects on their journey of connecting with art, from initially finding museums uninteresting to developing a deep appreciation for the stories and emotions behind each piece. They share a memorable experience with their girlfriend at a museum, where they felt a profound connection to the artist through a series of impressionistic landscapes. The speaker also contemplates the value of art education and the potential limitations of AI in truly understanding and appreciating the depth of art, emphasizing the unique human ability to find beauty and meaning in creative expression.


  • 🎨 The narrator's initial disinterest in museums transformed into a meaningful experience when visiting with their girlfriend, highlighting the importance of companionship in appreciating art.
  • 🖼️ A series of impressionistic landscape paintings left a lasting impact on the narrator, evoking a sense of familiarity and connection with the unknown artist.
  • 👀 The narrator's observation of the paintings allowed them to almost hear the artist's brush and visualize the color mixing process, demonstrating the immersive nature of art.
  • 🌳 The shared love for bold brush strokes and the addition of imaginative colors in both the narrator's and the unknown artist's work forged an emotional bond across time.
  • 🏛️ The narrator's appreciation for museum paintings and cave art increased through their art education, showcasing how knowledge deepens one's understanding and enjoyment of art.
  • ✏️ The fundamentals of drawing and painting the narrator studied at university, such as value and composition, enhanced their ability to appreciate the beauty and skill in both historical and contemporary art.
  • 🌈 Cave art's beauty and expressive lines charged with energy yet precision are admired by the narrator, who is in awe of the ancient artists' skills.
  • 🤖 The narrator expresses concern about AI's impact on the art world, fearing that AI-generated images may lack the depth and value of human-created art.
  • 🎓 The importance of art education is emphasized as it allows individuals to grow and enrich their experience with the art world, rather than simply viewing it as a form of communication or ritual.
  • 👫 The narrator's experience in the museum with their girlfriend and their newfound appreciation for art show that understanding and knowledge are key to truly enjoying and connecting with art.
  • 💭 The narrator's contemplation on the future of art and the role of AI reflects a broader societal concern about the potential loss of human creativity and the unique value that human artists bring to the world.

Q & A

  • What type of place did the speaker take his girlfriend to on a date?

    -The speaker took his girlfriend to a small museum in his town.

  • How does the speaker typically feel when visiting museums?

    -The speaker usually feels bored or sleepy in museums, although he acknowledges that as an artist, he should enjoy them.

  • What was significant about the series of paintings the speaker saw at the museum?

    -The series of paintings left a strong, lasting impression on the speaker, giving him a sense of familiarity and connection with the artist, despite not remembering the individual paintings.

  • How did the speaker describe his own painting style?

    -The speaker loves to paint with big, bold brush strokes, often using just a few strokes to paint all the leaves of a tree and adding colors that he may not have seen but wanted to see.

  • What is the speaker's opinion on the value of cave art?

    -The speaker appreciates cave art not only as a form of communication or ritual but also as a medium of beauty, with skill and energy in the illustrations that rivals modern art.

  • Who is mentioned as having been inspired by cave art, and what was their reaction?

    -Picasso is mentioned, with a quote suggesting that he felt that no new inventions in art had been made since the cave paintings, although it is noted that the quote's authenticity is uncertain.

  • What concern does the speaker have about AI in relation to art?

    -The speaker is worried that AI might generate good images but lack the depth of understanding and appreciation that human artists have, leading to art without value or meaning.

  • How does the speaker's understanding of art change over time?

    -As the speaker studies art more, he begins to appreciate it more, seeing beauty where he was previously indifferent, and recognizing the layers of richness in a piece of art.

  • What does the speaker believe is necessary to fully appreciate art?

    -The speaker believes that while an art degree is not necessary to appreciate art, having more knowledge about it allows one to better understand and appreciate the art world.

  • How does the speaker's experience at the museum as an adult differ from his experience as a child?

    -As a child, the speaker found museums boring because he didn't understand what he was looking at. As an adult, with more knowledge and experience in art, he can now enter a museum and not want to leave, appreciating the depth and stories behind the art.



🎨 Art and Connection - A Personal Encounter

The speaker shares a personal experience of visiting a small museum with their girlfriend, despite not being fond of museums. They describe a series of paintings that left a lasting impression, evoking a sense of familiarity and connection with the artist, despite not knowing anything about them. The speaker reflects on their own love for painting, particularly with bold brush strokes, and how this experience made them feel closer to the artist. They also discuss the evolution of art from cave paintings to contemporary works, expressing admiration for the beauty and skill found in these ancient artworks. The speaker's journey through art education is highlighted, emphasizing the value of understanding art beyond its communicative or ritualistic purposes.


🤖 The Future of Art and AI - A Personal Perspective

In this paragraph, the speaker expresses concerns about the impact of AI on the art world, particularly the fear that AI might replace human artists. They argue that AI-generated art may lack depth and the personal connection that comes from an artist's life experiences and emotions. The speaker emphasizes the importance of understanding the 'why' behind a piece of art, something they believe AI artists or AI writers may not be able to fully grasp. They share their passion for learning and appreciating art, and how this enriches their life. The speaker concludes by encouraging others to delve deeper into art to experience its richness and to share this appreciation with fellow artists.




Art is a diverse range of human activities that involve the creation of visual, auditory, or performance-based works that express the creator's imagination, conceptual ideas, or technical skill. In the video, the speaker's appreciation for art is evident as they describe their experiences in a museum and their personal connection to the paintings they viewed. The term 'art' is used to encompass various forms of creative expression, including the cave paintings discussed and the speaker's own passion for painting with bold brush strokes.


A museum is an institution or a dedicated space, usually in a building or a room, that conserves, collects, researches, exhibits, and interprets material evidence of people and their environment. In the context of the video, the museum serves as a setting where the speaker and their girlfriend visit and where the speaker experiences a profound connection with the art pieces on display.


Impressionism is an art movement that began in the 19th century, characterized by small, thin brush strokes, open composition, and an emphasis on capturing the fleeting effects of light and color in a scene. The speaker in the video relates to the impressionistic landscapes they encountered, which evoked a sense of familiarity and connection to their own artistic style.


A palette in the context of painting is a flat surface, usually made of wood or plastic, on which an artist mixes their colors before applying them to a painting surface. It is an essential tool for artists, allowing them to create a wide range of colors and tones. In the video, the speaker imagines the artist mixing colors on his wooden palette, emphasizing the creative process behind the paintings.

💡Cave Art

Cave art refers to the paintings and carvings found on the walls and ceilings of caves, created by prehistoric humans. These artworks often depict animals, handprints, and other symbols, and are some of the earliest known forms of human artistic expression. In the video, the speaker reflects on the beauty and skill evident in cave art, drawing a parallel between the fundamental human need to create across different eras.


An artist is an individual who creates art, engaging in various forms of creative expression such as painting, drawing, sculpture, or other visual media. The term encompasses both the professional and amateur practitioners of the arts. In the video, the speaker identifies as an artist themselves and feels a connection to the unknown artists of the past, despite not knowing their personal stories.


Appreciation in this context refers to the recognition and enjoyment of the aesthetic or cultural value of art. It involves a deeper understanding and emotional response to the artwork, which can lead to a more profound connection with the piece. The speaker in the video demonstrates appreciation by connecting with the art on an emotional level and recognizing the skill and creativity behind it.


An aesthetic refers to the collective principles of beauty and art that guide the creation and appreciation of art, design, and other creative endeavors. It encompasses the visual, emotional, and intellectual aspects that contribute to the overall impression of an artwork. In the video, the speaker is drawn to a particular aesthetic of bold brush strokes and the expression of unseen colors, which resonates with their own artistic preferences.


Connection in the context of the video refers to the emotional or intellectual bond that the speaker feels with the art and artists they encounter. It is the sense of shared understanding or experience that transcends time and space, linking the viewer to the creator. The speaker feels a connection with the artists through their mutual appreciation and creation of art.


In the context of art, value refers to the worth or importance that is attributed to an artwork, both in terms of its monetary worth and its intrinsic qualities such as beauty, skill, or cultural significance. The speaker in the video appreciates the value of both the museum paintings and the cave art, recognizing the depth and richness that these pieces hold beyond their surface appearance.


AI, or artificial intelligence, refers to the development of computer systems that can perform tasks typically requiring human intelligence, such as learning, reasoning, problem-solving, perception, and language understanding. In the video, the speaker expresses concern about the impact of AI on the art world, fearing that it may not be able to fully appreciate or create art with the same depth and meaning as human artists.


The narrator takes his girlfriend to a small museum, despite not usually enjoying museums.

He is an artist but finds museums make him want to nap or escape.

A series of paintings at the museum left a lasting impression on him.

The paintings gave him a sense of familiarity, like seeing a distant relative.

The narrator connects with the artist through the aesthetic of the paintings, despite not knowing the artist's identity.

He loves to paint with bold brush strokes, similar to the technique he observed in the museum's paintings.

The narrator appreciates the beauty and skill in cave art from prehistoric times.

He studied the fundamentals of drawing and painting at university, rather than art theory or philosophy.

The narrator is amazed by the beauty and skill in cave paintings, created thousands of years ago.

He believes that our prehistoric ancestors had a need to create, beyond survival.

The narrator speculates that prehistoric art covered every available surface.

He wishes to see real cave art one day, but is content with images online for now.

Studying art has increased the narrator's appreciation for beauty in various forms.

The narrator is concerned that AI may not fully appreciate the depth of art it generates.

He believes that AI lacks the personal connection and story behind the art that human artists bring.

The narrator finds joy in the richness and depth of art, which he feels AI cannot replicate.

He shares his newfound appreciation for art with his girlfriend at the museum.

The narrator realizes that understanding art enhances his experience in museums.

He concludes that art appreciation is personal and enriching, only fully shared by fellow artists.