Midjourney vs Magnific.AI - Upscaler Comparison
TLDRIn this video, the host compares image upscaling using two different AI technologies: Midjourney and Magnific.AI. The original images were generated by Midjourney, and then upscaled using both Midjourney's own upscaler and Magnific.AI. The comparison is made at a 2x scale, and the video showcases various types of images including portraits, video game style images, landscapes, 3D renders, and illustrations. The host notes that using a prompt with Magnific.AI can add more detail to the images, but it's not always necessary. The comparison reveals that while both upscaling methods are usable, Magnific.AI generally provides more detail and a more realistic look, especially in landscapes and 3D renders. However, the host also points out that there are still some general AI upscaling issues present. The video concludes with a clear preference for Magnific.AI's upscaling quality, particularly in rendering more natural-looking portraits and detailed landscapes.
Takeaways
- ๐จ The video compares images upscaled using Midjourney and Magnific.AI, both starting from original images generated by Midjourney.
- ๐ The comparison uses a 2x upscale size to maintain fairness in the evaluation.
- ๐ผ๏ธ Various image types are evaluated, including portraits, video game style images, landscapes, 3D renders, and illustrations.
- ๐ The use of prompts with Magnific.AI can add more detail to images, but their effectiveness varies by image type.
- ๐ Notable improvements with Magnific.AI are observed in 3D render landscapes, where it provides more realistic details.
- ๐๏ธ In the portrait category, Magnific.AI delivers more detailed and textured results, appearing more natural compared to Midjourney's more 'airbrushed' look.
- ๐ A significant difference in the level of detail is seen in the Sci-Fi image upscaled by Magnific.AI, which looks more illustrative and defined.
- ๐ฟ When comparing landscapes, Magnific.AI's upscaled image shows better definition in rocks, leaves, and water, making it more realistic.
- ๐ฎ For video game assets, Magnific.AI provides clearer and more detailed panels and buttons, enhancing the overall image quality.
- ๐๏ธ The video concludes that, in general, Magnific.AI outperforms Midjourney in terms of detail and realism across the evaluated image types.
- ๐ข The creator invites viewers to share their thoughts and suggests further comparisons or experiments with Magnific.AI in future videos.
Q & A
What is the main topic of the video?
-The main topic of the video is a comparison between images upscaled using Magnific.AI and the upscaler in Midjourney.
What was the original image source used for the comparison?
-The original images used for the comparison were generated using Midjourney.
What type of images were upscaled for the comparison?
-The types of images upscaled for the comparison include portraits, video game style images, landscapes, 3D renders, and illustrations.
What upscale size was used to keep the comparison fair?
-To keep the comparison fair, a 2x upscale size was used for both Magnific.AI and Midjourney upscalers.
Did the use of a prompt make a difference in the image details?
-In some cases, using a prompt added more detail to the image, but in other cases, it did not make a significant difference.
What optimizer was initially tried for the science fiction and horror themed image?
-The science fiction and horror optimizer was initially tried, but the result was not liked as it became very horror-themed quickly.
Which optimizer was eventually used for the science fiction and horror themed image?
-The film and photography optimizer was used to upscale the science fiction and horror themed image, which kept the result more in line with the original.
In which software were the images compared?
-The images were compared in Lightroom.
What was the general observation regarding the definition of details in the upscaled images?
-Magnific.AI generally provided more definition and detail in the upscaled images compared to Midjourney, making them look more realistic.
How did the upscaled portraits from Midjourney appear?
-The upscaled portraits from Midjourney appeared heavily airbrushed with little definition in the skin and hair details.
Which upscaler performed better in rendering the 3D image?
-Magnific.AI performed better in rendering the 3D image, providing more definition and detail.
What was the final verdict on which upscaler provided better results overall?
-The final verdict was that Magnific.AI provided better results overall in terms of definition and detail in the upscaled images.
Outlines
๐จ Image Upscaling Comparison with Magnific AI and Mid Journey
The video begins with an introduction to the channel and the topic of the video, which is a comparison of image upscaling using Magnific AI and the native upscaler in Mid Journey. The original images used for the comparison were generated by Mid Journey, and the comparison is made using a 2x upscale size to maintain fairness. The video showcases a variety of image types, including portraits, video game style images, landscapes, 3D renders, and illustrations. The creator discusses the use of prompts and their impact on the level of detail in the upscaled images. The differences observed are particularly noted in 3D renders and landscapes, with less noticeable differences in portraits and video game style images. The video also touches on the unsuccessful use of a science fiction and horror optimizer and the preference for the film and photography optimizer for a cyberpunk neon landscape image. The comparison then moves into Adobe Lightroom, where the original Mid Journey creations are flagged in green, the Mid Journey upscaled images in red, and the Magnific upscaled images in purple. The detailed comparison highlights the differences in definition, realism, and detail between the upscaled images by both tools.
๐ผ๏ธ Detailed Analysis of Upscaled Images in Lightroom
The video continues with an in-depth analysis of the upscaled images within Lightroom. The comparison starts with a Sci-Fi image, noting that while the faces are not well-defined in the upscaled version, the main subjects, signs, and human figures are more well-defined compared to the original Mid Journey image. The rain effect is noted to be well-rendered in both upscales. An illustration is then compared, with the upscaled version from Magnific showing a stronger contrast and more defined bushes and grass. The landscape image comparison reveals a significant difference, with the Magnific upscale showing much more detail in rocks, leaves, and cliff formations, making it appear more realistic. The video game asset comparison highlights better definition in panels and buttons in the Magnific upscale. The 3D render comparison shows that while the main structure of the rocket and boosters are similar in both upscales, Magnific provides more detail in the supporting station at the back. Lastly, the portrait comparison reveals a significant difference, with the Magnific upscale offering more detail, texture, and a more natural look compared to the Mid Journey upscale, which appears more retouched and lacks skin texture.
๐ Final Thoughts on Image Upscaling and Viewer Engagement
The video concludes with the creator's final thoughts on the image upscaling comparison. It is noted that Magnific generally provides more detail and a more natural look in the upscaled images, particularly in portraits. The creator invites viewers to like the video, share their thoughts in the comments, and suggest further comparisons or experiments they would like to see, especially with Magnific AI. The video ends with a call to action for viewers to subscribe for more content.
Mindmap
Keywords
๐กAI Channel
๐กUpscale
๐กMidjourney
๐กMagnific.AI
๐ก2x Upscale
๐กPrompt
๐ก3D Render
๐กIllustration
๐กLightroom
๐กCyberpunk
๐กTexture
Highlights
This video compares images upscaled using Magnific.AI and Midjourney's in-built upscaler.
All original images were generated using Midjourney.
The comparison uses a 2x upscale size for fairness.
Different types of images, including portraits, video game style images, landscapes, 3D renders, and illustrations, were used.
Using a prompt can make a difference in the detail of the upscaled image.
Notable differences were observed in 3D render landscapes.
The Sci-Fi image comparison shows more definition and realism in the upscaled image by Magnific.AI.
Illustration comparison reveals a slight edge for Magnific.AI due to added details.
Landscape images upscaled by Magnific.AI show significantly more detail and realism.
Video game asset comparison indicates better definition in the upscaled image by Magnific.AI.
3D render comparison shows Magnific.AI rendering more detailed supporting structures.
Portrait comparison reveals a more realistic and detailed result by Magnific.AI, with better skin texture and hair definition.
The upscaled portrait by Midjourney appears more retouched and lacks texture compared to Magnific.AI.
Magnific.AI's upscaled images show more natural skin textures and details.
The video concludes that Magnific.AI generally provides better results in upscaling images.
The presenter invites viewers to share their thoughts and suggestions for future comparisons or experiments.